8 Best Natural rubber pacifiers blog post

8 Best Natural Rubber Pacifiers For Babies

The Best Non-Toxic Pacifiers To Safely Help Soothe Baby

This post contains affiliate links which may earn us a commission.

Choosing a pacifier for your baby can be quite confusing—there are just so many out there.

And even if you think you’ve purchased “the one”, your new baby will most likely hate it. It happens, and it’s ok. There will be a lot of trial and error in your motherhood journey.

That’s why I encourage all new moms to introduce a natural rubber pacifier to their babies in lieu of silicone. And there are many reasons for this that just make sense—especially if you are breastfeeding. Let’s look at some below.

How Are Natural Rubber Pacifiers Different From Silicone

Unlike silicone pacifiers, natural rubber pacifiers mimic the shape and softness of a mother’s breast. This flexible and stretchy material creates an easy back-and-forth transition for a breastfed baby.

Natural rubber pacifiers are also eco-friendly, sustainable and biodegradable. They are made with minimal ingredients, and do not require a plastic frame with handle).

With that said, the manufacturing process leaves out parabans, phthalates, BPA, and other unhealthy additives.

How To Sterilize A Natural Rubber Pacifier

Natural rubber pacifiers need to be sterilized like any other pacifier. However, because they are made from natural material, it is best to boil them just once (before initial use) to prevent damage from the high heat.

Future sterilization requires that you put the pacifiers in a bowl, and simply pour boiling water over them. This scalding method is a gentle yet thorough way to kill germs and bacteria without damaging your natural rubber pacifiers.

  • Put the pacifiers in a clean bowl
  • Pour them with boiling water
  • Let the pacifiers soak for approx. 5 min.
  • Pick them up and let them dry

How Often Should I Replace A Natural Rubber Pacifier?

Since natural rubber pacifiers don’t last as long as their silicone competitor, you will need to change your baby’s pacifier every 4-8 weeks.

The nipples of natural rubber pacifiers will eventually expand, change shape and even turn gooey, so it’s very important to have another one on hand, and switch it out as soon as you see this type of wear.

But giving your baby a pacifier that’s safe for both them and the planet is well worth a few new swaps!

With that said, below are 5 most trusted natural rubber pacifier brands that moms and babies love!

The 5 Best Organic Pacifiers To Help Soothe Your Baby

1. BibsUSA Natural Rubber Pacifiers

The BIBS natural rubber baby pacifier mimics both the shape and softness of a mothers’ breast. Their classic appearance captures a look that’s both timeless and elegant.  All BIBS pacifiers are made in Denmark from 100% natural latex and are lead and pthalate free.


  • 100% natural rubber
  • Rounded nipple design to mimic breast
    Designed and manufactured in Denmark
  • 100% free of BPA, PVC and phthalates
  • Sold in packs of 2

2. Natursutten Natural Rubber Pacifiers

Made from pure, all-natural latex rubber from the Hevea Brasiliense tree, Natursutten natural rubber pacifiers are softer than silicone and are extremely hygienic because they are molded in one piece. By gently touching baby’s nose, Natursutten pacifiers are designed to closely simulate breastfeeding, which provides a more familiar soothing experience for your baby.


  • Made from liquid rubber milk from sustainably harvested rubber trees
  • Safe one piece design
  • Handmade in Italy
  • No BPA, phthalates, or chemical softening agents

3. Hevea Natural Rubber Pacifiers

Hevea organic pacifiers are made from 100% natural rubber from HEVEA trees, and feature a silky smooth touch that is gentle on baby’s face and teeth. These eco-friendly pacifiers are completely plant-based and biodegradable at the end of their life, and feature safe, FDA Approved color pigments—it’s actually one of the only colored natural rubber pacifiers on the market!


  • 100% natural rubber from the sap of Hevea trees
  • Orthodontic design promotes proper teeth alignment
  • Uniquely designed ventilation holes
  • Hygienic solid design – eliminates bacteria
  • Pack of two pacifiers
Frigg Natural Rubber Pacifier

4. Frigg Natural Rubber Pacifiers

FRIGG natural rubber pacifiers are designed and manufactured in Denmark, and each one contains a whimsical design that moms love. The outward curve keeps the pacifier off of baby’s delicate skin, while other features like air holes and a security handle ensure that your little one stays safe.


  • Made from 100% natural rubber
  • Contains a flower petal design and breathable holes
    100% free from BPA, PVC and phthalates.
  • Sold in packs of 2
  • Designed and manufactured in Denmark.
Eco Piggy Natural Rubber Pacifier

5. EcoPiggy Natural Rubber Pacifiers

EcoPiggy natural pacifiers are sustainably made from 100% natural rubber, and designed in one single-piece. This nontoxic pacifier contains no choking hazards and is BPA, phthalate, PVC, and paraben-free. Plus, they’re hand-inspected and packaged in the USA!


  • Sustainably made from 100% natural rubber
  • Single piece design
  • Round shield lightly touches the child’s nose, simulating the soothing feel of breast feeding
    Plastic-free, bpa-free, pvc-free, paraben-free, no chemical-softeners, no colorants
Itzy Ritzy Natural Organic Pacifier

6. Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifiers

The Itzy Ritzy Soother pacifier features a silicone body and cherry-shaped natural rubber nipple that is designed to closely mimic the feel of breastfeeding. 


  • The natural rubber nipple is cherry-shaped to closely mimic breastfeeding 
  • The handle of each pacifier features precious cable detailing 
  • Meet ASTM safety standards and are BPA free
  • Sold as a 2-pack of coordinating pacifiers 
Zoe b natural rubber pacifier

7. Zoë B Natural Rubber Pacifier

The Zoë B Simply Rubber Pacifiers are made as one piece and contain symmetrical nipples which closely resemble a mother’s breasts. They are made from the highest quality Hevea tree, and hand-crafted in Italy.


  • Eco-Friendly
    100% pure natural rubber pacifier soft and natural rounded nipple
  • Safe one piece design
  • Tamper-proof packaging
  • Handcrafted In Italy
Sweetie natural rubber pacifier

8. Sweetie Natural Rubber Pacifier

The Sweetie organic rubber pacifiers are made as one piece and contain symmetrical round nipples to mimic a mother’s breast.


  • Eco-Friendly
  • 100% pure natural rubber pacifier soft and natural Rounded nipple
  • Safe one piece design
  • No BPA, nitrosamines, PVC, phthalates, chemical softeners, or artificial dyes
  • Conforms standard EN1400 Pacifier

Success! You're on the list.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s